Vision science · game legibility

Pop-out

What the eye picks out before you start to search, and how to make it pick the right thing

Feature search

One difference is found at once, however many cells

The mutant is the one odd cell: tap it. With 60 cells it takes no longer than with 8.

Conjunction search

A combination must be searched cell by cell

Combination: only the mutant is violet and spiky; every other cell is one or the other.

Reading the graph

Time to find: flat for one difference, rising for a combination

one differencecombination flat: more cells, no more timerising: about 25 ms more for every cell one point is one search: across, howmany cells; up, how long it took hollow dots: your own taps, which sithigher (a tap is slower than a key press)

Why it happens

Each feature gets its own map; a lone lit spot draws the eye

violet map spiky map

Slowed down here: a real eye checks about 40 cells a second.

Search asymmetry

The one cell with a tail pops out; the one without does not

tail map

Similarity

Pop-out needs a gap between the mutant and the rest

each tick: one cell's hue

In the game's own dish

Show hunger by size, and only the mutant lights the violet map

violet map

Recap

What the dish showed

  1. One difference is found at once, however many cells
  2. Violet and spiky together is searched cell by cell
  3. One difference: flat; combination: about 25 ms more per cell
  4. A lone lit spot on a map draws the eye
  5. A tail pops out; a missing tail does not
  6. A closer hue or more varied neighbours closes the gap
  7. Hunger as size leaves the violet map to the mutant