Evolutionary ecology · game balance

Trade-offs

Why no strain wins everywhere, and what keeps several alive

Why the two traits trade off

One food budget: more reach means thinner walls

spread: how far the veinsreach (the dashed ring) hardiness: the violetwall round each vein rose drops are toxin: theycut thin-walled veins back food budget veinswalls spread hardiness

Reading the graph

One strain is one point

curve: all food spent ↑ higher: thicker walls further right: veins reach further inside: some foodspent on neither

drag the point

Pareto dominance

A strain beaten at both traits never wins

curve: all food spent grey: another strain hasmore of both; the boxruns to it Pareto front:none beaten at both

drag a strain onto or off the curve

Which point on the Pareto front

The mix of agar and toxin picks the winner

hardiness specialist: all walls spread specialist:all veins generalists curve: all food spent growth = spread × agar share + hardiness × toxin share growth = spread × agar share+ hardiness × toxin share

Convex or concave

Diminishing returns favour generalists, accelerating ones specialists

linear 0.50 straight line between the specialists bars: share of dish mixes won

When no strain is best

A rock-paper-scissors loop survives only with local contact

beatsbeatsbeats

Recap

What the dish showed

  1. One food budget: veins that reach further get thinner walls
  2. One strain is one point: reach across, walls up
  3. Beaten at both never wins; unbeaten strains: the Pareto front
  4. The mix of agar and toxin picks the winner
  5. Diminishing returns: generalists win; accelerating returns: only specialists
  6. Rock-paper-scissors strains coexist locally; stirring kills two